Chapter One — The Study of Folklore and Folk Groups
Ch 5 Linguistic analysis
Chapter One
The Study of Folklore and Folk Groups For many members of the general public, folklore is thought to be something that is false—a tall tale, for example. However, folklorists define the term in a different manner. To them, folklore is the transmission of culture within a folk group. Such folk groups have common identifiers such as ethnicity, occupation, religion, gender, recreation or geographic location. Though individuals may perform them, folklore traditions ultimately belong to communities and serve to identify these groups (Brunvand 3). Contrary to popular belief, folk traditions are not fading in America. Instead, they change and adapt with the times and the changing worldview of groups. Furthermore, these traditions are not things that only the senior demographic of society can related to, and they are traditions that every group has. Despite the constant changes in a culture, whether in its periods of growth or decline, its traditions change and grow. This phenomenon of evolution of traditions is especially apparent in times of major social change.
Folklife is a term used interchangeably for folklore, though Brunvand says folklife is better defined as a subset of folklore. Certainly, the term folklife is better suited to the customs of everyday life, such basket weaving, than to jokes or legends. It also accounts for a significant portion of traditions within a folk group, specifically those that are learned by simply growing up within a particular culture. By their nature, these folklife traditions are more complex than folklore. The etymology of the word “folklore”—“folk” meaning the common people and “lore” implying an understanding in words—denotes oral transmission (Brunvand 503).
Material culture takes folklore to a deeper level that is intrinsic to the everyday life of a culture rather than a joke to be learned or a story to be told. The worth of material culture is illustrated in works such as Henry Glassie’s cultural-geographic work Passing the Time in Balleymenone which offers fine cultural detail as well as rich background dating back generations. Common people throughout the ages have spent the majority of their lives trying to survive and better their lives. As a result, occupational traditions readily lend themselves to a holistic methodology, giving such simple devices as jokes and riddles deeper meaning. As McCarl notes in his essay “Occupational Folklore”:
The study of occupational folklore in the United States parallels the evolution of folklore methodology in general, from the desire of the early ballad collectors to rescue surviving ballads and songs, to the impact of European-inspired interest in skill and material expression, to the more recent interest in the intersection between work culture, class, ethnicity and gender. (522)
Such defining characteristics as work, class, ethnicity and gender, provide the context for understanding a people. Their traditions shape and color them. To truly understand the traditions of a folk group, folklorists give attention to both oral and material customs in order to present a complete picture of the group they are studying. In the Handbook of American Folklore, Bauman makes the case that recorded traditions are useless independent of contextual meaning and provides six points for contextual study:
The fieldworker seeking to comprehend folklore in terms of the web of contextual interrelationships that define its essence will find it useful to organize the gathering of field data around the six broad foci outlined above: (a) context of meaning (what does it mean?); (b) institutional context (where does it fit within the culture?); (c) context of communicative system (how does it relate to other kinds of folklore?); (d) social base (what kind of people does it belong to?); (e) individual context (how does it fit into a person’s life); (f) context of situation (how useful is it in social situations?). (367)
Bauman’s argument demonstrates the need to establish folklore as culture rather than an independent act or event. Past folklorists, including John Lomax, were concerned with recording incidences of folklore, causing the purpose that the lore served to become lost (Hirsch 449). Today, folklorists assign more importance to interdependencies of cultural context and folk traditions, clearing the path to a better understanding of the cultures being studied.
During times of crisis or significant change, folk traditions serve a purpose. They may provide a sense of familiarity and safety even though some of the original reasoning behind a particular bit of lore may have been forgotten. For example, folkore may serve a cautionary function related to morality or common household dangers. It also may be born out of need, as in the case of some material folklore such as woodworking.
In examining a folk group or community, the interaction of members is critical to the understanding and interpretation of the community’s culture. Members of a folk group must have what Elliot Oring calls a “consciousness of kind” and a dynamic that conditions them to the possibility of activity based on this consciousness (24). When this activity is transmitted, it becomes folklore and the folk group is legitimized. Numerous sociological approaches to folklore have been put forth over the past one hundred years of folklore studies. In American Folklore: An Encyclopedia, Gary Alan Fine outlines the empirical areas of sociological study of folklore. These areas include (1) impression management and performance, which address the individual’s esteem needs as expressed through performance within his or her chosen social group (2) group dynamics and the creation of folk groups, which focus on how meaning is created within the group, (3) social control and social conflict, which establish the formation and meaning of social structure within a society and (4) nation building and social change, which examine how change evolves new traditions (676).
Each of the empirical areas mentioned above are featured prominently in the folklore of the Southern region of the United States. The South is particularly rich in folklore due to its social constructions based in the perpetuation of community and family traditions. Further, southerners are characterized by their propensity to retain their customs: “…the South is a region of retentions, where traditions once shared with other parts of the country have been maintained after disappearing elsewhere. This can be attributed to the isolation of the dispersed farming population from centers of change, poverty following the Civil War and a conservative tendency to cling to the old ways” (Bulger 680). “The Old Ways” Bulger refers to still endure throughout Southern folklore. Brunvand’s general guidelines for identifying folklore state, first, that the folklore’s content is transmitted orally or by material demonstration; second, its form and transmission are traditional; third, various versions of it exist; and, fourth, it becomes formularized (12). In small communities, and especially the rural communities throughout the twentieth-century American South, oral transmission of traditions dominated these cultures because labor skills that could be used in farming, household, and factory work took precedence over reading and writing skills.
The documented narratives in this thesis reflect a community well aware of its past even while it struggles to chart a new course for itself amid uncertainty not seen since its founding. The stories that follow are the stories of people who not only made homes in the town of Castor, Louisiana, but have established themselves as members of its culture. Previously documented only in local histories and newspaper articles, the town provides ample opportunity for further analysis of its folk traditions. The town’s enduring interdependence with the timber industry, even in spite of the recent closing of its industrial centerpiece, provides a rare opportunity for further study.